GET THE GUIDE

Our 3 day meal plan allows you to lose weight, without having to give up the foods you love or hiring an expensive personal trainer.
» » » 10 Best Eye Makeup Removers | Avoid These Chemicals For Healthy Looking Skin

10 Best Makeup Remover Product Reviews

 

Choosing the best makeup remover or the best eye makeup remover to clean your skin can be a hard mission; there are so many brands, how do you choose? This is why we wrote a detailed review of the best eye makeup removers and makeup remover wipes, to help you choose the right one, based on your skin type. Here at The Nutritional Source, I have dedicated time and research to provide you with the 10 best makeup remover products for your skin based on their ingredients and results.

 

You most likely wake up each morning, and have someone else do your makeup for you like this:

 

Just kidding…

 

But, depending on which makeup remover you use, you most likely look like this at night when you go to remove your makeup:

 

Or maybe you totally forget to remove your makeup altogether because you’re too tired and will be taking a shower the next morning…

 

But…

 

Did you know that sleeping with makeup on can actually damage your skin?

 

So it is important to use one of the best makeup removers to cleanse your face before bed each night. Improperly using makeup removers can dry out your skin and cause it to flake!

 

According to the University of Pennsylvania, and Dr. Albert Kligman, it is recommended to remove your makeup and moisturize your skin every night. Do not use soap, advises Dr. George Cotsarelis, also a member of the Pennsylvania University;

 

“The point of soap is to remove oil, but the skin needs some oil and moisture.”

 

This means that if you remove too much of either, your skin will become dry or produce excess oil.

 

The under eye area needs extra attention!

 

Dermatologist John R. Stanley warns that your eye skin is so thin, if it gets irritated, it will be significantly more noticeable than the rest of your skin.

 

You will want to avoid makeup remover wipes and eye makeup remover containing parabens, as it is shown in studies to influence the aging process.

 

Collagen is the main substance for young and soft looking skin. It is the loss of collagen that causes the aging appearance and inconsistencies in your skin. The overall collagen content per unit area of skin is known to decline approximately 1% per year, according to research. With your collagen levels declining, you must find a way to reset them!

 


 

But how do you reset your collagen? According to studies, there are two different ways to slow collagen degradation. That is an entirely different topic I will need to write about in another topic.

 

But…

 

A good way to prevent wrinkles is the reduction of inflammation with topical or systemic antioxidants which should be used in combination with sunscreens and retinoids to enhance their protective effects.

 

Vitamins C and E are the most important elements to look for in the best makeup remover due to their capacity to penetrate the skin and destroy free radicals, therefore protecting your skin collagen.

 

Vitamin A acts as a cell regulator and stimulates the production of collagen and elastic fibers.

 

Aloe vera is another ingredient you should look for in a makeup remover. This plant extract has shown in studies to improve the hydration in your skin. Aloe vera aids in moisturizing, anti-aging, correction of superficial epidermal cells, tightening of pores and fights acne.

 

When a woman transitions into menopause, her skin can lose up to 30% of its collagen during the first five years. One clinical trial found that using argon oil can increase your skin elasticity after 60 days of use.

 

I like to keep our selections of the best eye makeup removers natural and healthy, so it’s important to consider ingredients such as herbal oils.

 

According to one research study, herbal extracts, juices, and oils are beneficial elements in skincare products.

 

Grapefruit seed, cucumber, basil, almond and jojoba oil can restore skin hydration. One clinical trial has shown the use of avocado oil to significantly increase collagen content in your skin too.

 

With this brief overview, you will be able to choose the best makeup remover for your skin. Let’s get started.

 

Overview: The Best Makeup Remover Wipes and Liquids 

 

best makeup remover for face

 

The first on the list of the best eye makeup remover wipes is the Neutrogena Hydrating Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes. This makeup remover wipe is practical and easy to carry with you. The main highlight of this makeup remover is that these makeup remover wipes can take off even your waterproof makeup.

 

They do this without damaging your skin. These makeup remover wipes contain cucumber and aloe extracts, which are proven to improve skin collagen and hydration.

 

The second best makeup remover on the list is the Foxbrim Makeup Remover & Facial Oil. It’s a 100% natural formula containing restoration ingredients such as organic grapefruit seed oil, avocado oil, and jojoba oil. These ingredients can stimulate your collagen production and hydrate your skin, according to studies.

 

Banila Clean It Zero Sherbet Makeup Cleanser is a Korean cream based makeup remover. The Sherbet Cleanser differs from the first two as it must be applied to your hands.

 

To use this product, you simply massage the cream onto your face and wash it off with water. As a plus, this product is made from papaya extract, which possesses antioxidant properties, according to research.

 

Similar to the first makeup remover, the Kareway Epielle Argan Oil Makeup Remover Wipes also come in towelette form. However, this product is comprised of a different formula, containing argan oil and vitamin E. While argan oil has proven to improve the skin elasticity in women, vitamin E has properties which protect your skin’s collagen.

 

If you are looking for an alcohol-free makeup remover, the Thayers Alcohol-free Rose Petal Witch Hazel with Aloe Vera Makeup Remover is the right one for you! This makeup remover is also paraben and propylene glycol free. The ingredients include, aloe vera, hazel and rose fragrance.

 

The Beauty By Earth Makeup Remover is a product for people who have acne, sensitive skin, dry skin or even oily skin! This makeup remover is oil free.

 

It is comprised of organic ingredients such as aloe vera, hazel extract, cucumber extract and green tea. According to studies, the properties present in green tea leafs can prevent UVB light-induced skin disorders, including aging and skin cancer.

 

Next, on my list of the best makeup removers, comes the Derma-Nu Makeup Remover & Cleansing Milk. If you do not like the fragrance of most makeup removers, this one should suit you perfectly.

 

Its formula is aroma and paraben free. It contains aloe vera, coconut oil, grapefruit seed extract and vitamin E for the hydrated and soft skin. It’s great for those with sensitive skin.

 

The La Fresh Makeup Remover Cleansing Wipes are pre-moistened wipes for practical makeup removal. They are packed in small portions to fit better in your purse. They contain vitamin E, which regulates cells and helps to control aging.

 

Remember I told you how important collagen is for your skin appearance? The French Nerds Makeup Remover Wipes are cleansing wipes that can be used for your eyes and face.

 

These makeup wipes are infused with vitamin A, C, E and aloe vera, which are antioxidant substances to preserve and stimulate your facial collagen production. French Nerds Makeup Remover is a source of anti-aging agents.

 

If you are looking for a special product to remove eye makeup, the Mary Kay Eye Makeup Remover is the one. It comes in the last spot on our list, but not for any particular reason.

 

This eye makeup remover is suitable for sensitive skin and has been clinically tested for allergens. It has a very nice texture that allows you to take off heavy mascara and eye shadows without damaging your skin.

 

At A Glance: Our Choices for The Best Makeup Remover for Face

 

Among the top five brands we’ve picked, these are all great makeup removers while keeping your skin health in mind. Let’s take a look at the best makeup removers together.

 

1. Neutrogena Hydrating Makeup Remover Towelettes

1_neutrogena-towellets-copyThe Neutrogena Hydrating Makeup Remover Cleansing Wipes come as pre-moistened cloths. They are used to directly clean your skin, removing dirt and makeup. They are able to remove waterproof makeup easily! Besides the cleansing properties, this product contains aloe and cucumber extracts, which provides hydration to your skin.

 

According to reviews, the Neutrogena Hydrating Makeup Remover Cleansing Wipes are well saturated and work well to remove eye makeup. Users claimed that these makeup remover wipes leave your skin clean and moisturized. Others have complained about the strong and lasting fragrance of the makeup remover wipes.

 

Some also experienced allergic reactions, along with dry wipes after a short time. Buy the smaller pack to try them out and make sure you like them before you go and spend a ton of money 🙂

 

pros-and-cons

2. Foxbrim Eye Makeup Remover & Facial Oil

 

2_foxbrim-copy

 

The Foxbrin Eye Makeup Remover & Facial Oil is a 100% natural product! Besides its cleansing properties, this makeup remover contains ingredients such as grapefruit seed, avocado, macadamia, tamanu and jojoba oil to hydrate and restore your skin.

 

Following the manufacturer’s instructions, you will use the Foxbrin Eye Makeup Remover & Facial Oil with a cotton ball or pad and softly wipe your face.

 

Users have reported that this makeup remover easily removes mascara and other stubborn makeup.

 

It is also considered a great moisturizer as it makes your skin soft and healthy. Some people have said that this eye makeup remover can be used on sensitive skin areas, such as around the eyes. However, among the reviews, there are some users who don’t feel that this makeup remover is quite as effective as others.

 

pros-and-cons-1

 

3. Banila Clean It Zero Sherbet Eye Makeup Remover

 

3_banila-clean-copy

 

The Banila Clean It Zero Sherbet Cleanser is a cream based eye makeup remover. It is meant to be spread across your face and massaged into your skin. After that, it must be washed off with water. This Korean makeup remover contains papaya extract, which gives it its antioxidant properties.

 

Users have reported that the Banila Clean It Zero Sherbet Cleanser leaves your skin soft and clean. It has a nice consistency and removes all the makeup in the first application. Some reviews say that the product has an unpleasant smell, that it can cause allergies and that is not made for sensitive skin.

 

pros-and-cons-2

 

4. Kareway Epielle Argan Oil Makeup Remover Wipes

 

4_kareway-toweletts-copy

 

The Kareway Epielle Argan Oil Makeup Remover comes in towelette form. It contains cleansing elements, argan oil, aloe vera and vitamin E. These makeup remover wipes can remove waterproof mascara, they are hypoallergenic and oil free. They are pre-moistened and don’t need to be rinsed.

 

According to reviews, the Kareway Epielle Argan Oil Makeup Remover is great for dry skin and can help to treat enlarged pores. The argan oil was also highlighted by customers as being a strong moisturizer. Some users have complained that this makeup remover has an unpleasant fragrance and may further wrinkles.

 

pros-and-cons-3

 

5. Thayers Alcohol-free Rose Petal Witch Hazel with Aloe Vera

5_thayers-copy

 

Thayers Alcohol-Free Rose Petal makeup remover is paraben, propylene glycol, and of course, alcohol-free. In its formula, you will find vitamin E, aloe vera, hazel, rose and grapefruit seed extract. It’s hypoallergenic and besides cleaning your skin, it hydrates and tones your skin as well!

 

Users have said that this eye makeup remover can help treat acne and oily skin, as well as being a toner. Some customers have experienced blemishes and redness after using this product.

 

pros-and-cons-4

 

6. Beauty By Earth Makeup Remover

 

6_beauty-and-earth-copy

 

This makeup remover contains aloe vera, hazel extract, cucumber extract, green tea and other organic ingredients. It’s 100% cruelty-free! It should be gently wiped onto your face with a cotton ball or pad.

 

Users say this makeup remover is refreshing, aromatic and great for oily skin. Some reviews have reported that the Beauty By Earth Makeup Remover is not effective on waterproof makeup and has a thick consistency.

 

pros-and-cons-5

 

7. Derma-Nu Makeup Remover & Cleansing Milk

 

7_derma_nu-copy

 

The Derma-Nu Makeup Remover & Cleansing Milk contains 70% organic ingredients in its formula. The ingredients include aloe vera, coconut oil, apricot oil, grapefruit seed oil and honey. It has no fragrance, it is paraben free and has never been tested on animals.

 

It is suggested to apply a small amount to your fingertips to remove makeup around your eyes or use a cotton pad for other areas.

 

Users have highlighted that this product is very gentle on your skin and has satisfying moisturizing properties. Some reviews have reported that this makeup remover isn’t effective on waterproof mascara and long-wear products.

 

pros-and-cons-6

 

8. La Fresh Makeup Remover

 

8_travel-copy

 

La Fresh Makeup Remover comes in pre-moistened makeup remover wipes used to remove any kind of makeup, including waterproof mascara. They are individually wrapped for traveling. It contains vitamin E as a nourishing element in its formula.

 

Some reviews have highlighted the easy use of the product and how it’s practical to carry with you. Users have also said that this makeup remover is effective and doesn’t damage your skin.

 

Some customers have complained about the strong aroma of this product and have experienced allergies.

 

pros-and-cons-7

 

9. French Nerds Makeup Remover Towelettes

 

9_french-nerds-copy

 

French Nerds Makeup Remover Towelettes are a source of anti-aging antioxidants that fight free radicals. The cleansing wipes contain aloe vera, vitamins A, C, and E, which are proven to preserve and restore collagen in your skin. They are soft and used normally around your eye area. The towelettes also don’t need to be rinsed.

 

Some users have said that the wipes are very effective at removing makeup. It is also said to be a fantastic moisturizer for nourished and soft skin. Reviews have reported, however, the wipes are not wet enough to remove some makeup products.

 

pros-and-cons-8

 

10. Mary Kay Eye Makeup Remover

10_marykay-copy

 

Mary Kay Eye Makeup Remover is the best eye makeup remover out there. It’s suitable for sensitive skin, clinically tested for allergies, ophthalmologist tested, fragrance-free and safe for those who use contact lenses.

 

Mary Kay Eye Makeup Remover must be applied with a cotton ball, according to the manufacturer.

 

Users have said that this eye makeup remover is very effective and that no rinse is required. Some have also said is gentle on their skin.

 

Reviews have reported that the Mary Kay Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover doesn’t work for some mascara and that it has an oily texture.

 

pros-and-cons-9

 

Conclusion

 

In addition to using the best makeup removers from my list, I’d like to remind you to always use sunscreen.

 

One clinical trial has shown that daily use of sunscreen can decrease up to 24% of skin aging. Sunscreen helps you to protect yourself against skin cancer.

 

Keep in mind, all of these are some of the best eye makeup remover products out there. They all have cleansing properties and nourishing elements to avoid dry and flaky skin.

 

Some of these eye makeup removers also contain anti-aging ingredients. Regardless what you need, these 10 best makeup removers have you covered.

 

It’s important to emphasize that some makeup remover wipes can please some people more than others.

 

 

What are some of the best eye makeup remover products you have used? Anything you would lie to share? Comment in the section below 🙂

Keep In Touch

Average Rating: 4.9
Votes: 341
Reviews: 506
body.et_non_fixed_nav.et_transparent_nav.et_secondary_nav_enabled #main-header, body.et_fixed_nav.et_secondary_nav_enabled #main-header { top: 0px; }